Student Stumper 33: Is “would” more polite than “could”?

QUESTION: What’s the difference between would and could?

ANSWER: This question was posted on my forum, and it began a discussion on modals. I first explored differences in meaning. I listed uses of would, including future in the past (You promised you would tell me!) and habitual past (When I was a child, I would ask my grandmother to tell me stories.) Then I explained how could expresses past ability (When Grandma was younger, she could do a cartwheel!) Finally, I noted the overlap in making requests, showing how the two verbs could be interchangeable (Would you please help me?/ Could you please help me?) This is when the student asked if it was correct to assume that “would” is more polite than “could.”

A funny thing happens when you are asked to commit to an answer and put it in print for possibly a hundred or more pairs of eyes to read. You sometimes doubt what you had previously felt certain about. Are “would” and “could” equally polite? I thought so. I did some reflection… and I still think so.

I believe one factor that equalizes these two modal verbs is pronunciation. Either verb could become rude with a change in sentence stress and intonation. For example, compare “Could you please pick that up?” and “Could you please pick that up?!” (Click here to listen.) In these examples, the modal would can be used to perform the same function: (1) make a polite request with no demand or urgency/ (2) make an impatient request born out of frustration.

In terms of choosing between would and could, we can help students by explaining that certain structures suit specific situations best. Examples:

1. would you like = Would you like to sit down? (polite offer/ invitation)

2. would you mind = Would you mind moving down one seat? (tentative request with some worry that it will cause offense, inconvenience, etc.)

3. would it be possible = Would it be possible for you to pick me up on your way to work? (similar to would you mind, used to make an inquiry about a desired action/ request for a favor)

Can you think of any others?


7 Comments Add yours

  1. Deirdre says:

    Interesting comments there – it will no doubt get me thinking which is always useful. I have that same feeling about believing I know the answer, then when asked to commit (sometimes to only a few people) I start to doubt myself. Maybe it’s a good thing – prevents complacency!
    Deirdre – English_York

    1. I’m glad I’m not alone in my doubts!
      Thanks for commenting, Deirdre.

  2. Niyi Ade says:

    It is not only the two modals which confuse ESL. There is need for more clarification on how to use Should. Have YouTube for them

    1. Modals are on my list of topcis to be covered on YouTube. 🙂

  3. Nina Liakos says:

    I agree that “would you please” and “could you please” are equivalent in terms of formality. “Can you please” and “will you please” are less formal. “Will” might be more polite (formal) than “can”. Do you agree?

    1. Hm. I’m not sure I see “will” as always being more polite than “can.” Again, don’t you think it depends on pronunciation (stress, intonation, and reduction)? Compare:
      1. Will you please help me? (sweetly said)
      2. Excuse me. Can you help me, please? (gently and respectfully said)
      3. Will ya help me? Come on. Help me out here! (said impatiently)
      Ah, language. As you said in another comment, we ESL/ EFL teachers merely try to describe the langauge. Our “rules” certainly can’t control it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s