Student Stumper 24: Causative Verbs

QUESTION: What are causative verbs? Can you give me a list of them?

ANSWER: “Causative verbs [...] indicate that some person or thing helps to bring about a new state of affairs” (Biber, Conrad & Leech 108).  In other words, we use a causative verb to show that someone or something somehow causes something to happen. The verb might be strong in meaning and imply force, for example, I make students rewrite their work. The verb might be soft in meaning and imply facilitating or permitting, for instance, I let them turn in their homework late. In contrast to definining causative verbs, providing a complete list may prove to be more of a challenge. 

A student recently sent e-mail asking me to identify all causative verbs in English. She had learned only four (let, make, have, get), but another classmate told her there were many more. She wanted to know what those others were. This forced me to search my books for a supposedly complete list of causative verbs. All the sources I consulted named only a few examples beyond the more common ones: let, make, have, and get. Hmm…

I suppose the choice of presenting only the four abovementioned causative verbs is based on their high frequency and their relatively unique grammar, at least in the case of let, make, and have, as in “Let them enter.” = causative verb + object + base verb. This pattern isn’t followed by get or most other verbs in the same semantic class, such as allow, enable, or require. Compare: “Allow them to enter.” = causative verb + object + infinitive.  Fuchs and Bonner offer a list of verbs using this second pattern (A-3, Chart 5). This list includes 32 verbs:

advise, allow, ask, cause, challenge, choose, convince, enable, encourage, expect, forbid, force, get, help, hire, invite, need, order, pay, permit, presuade, promise, remind, request, require, teach, tell, urge, want, warn, wish, would like

Note that the list is not titled “Causative Verbs” but rather “Verbs Followed by Objects and the Infinitive”. The very title makes me consider causative verbs from two different standpoints. First and foremost, we should view them as a semantic class of verbs. We’re grouping them by their common meaning and purpose in speech, which is to express how an event is somehow caused. However, attention needs to be given to the different grammatical patterns they follow. The Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English divides causative verbs into two groups:

  1. Causative verbs  with nominalized direct objects  = “This information enables the formulation of precise questions” (363).
  2. Causative verbs with following complement clauses = “What caused you to be ill?” (363) / “Police and council leaders agreed to let a court decide the fate of the trees” (363).

Based on the examples given, I see the second group breaking down further into at least two subgroups, clauses using the infinitive and clauses using the base verb. Would you agree?

I’m still not certain if I could offer a truly complete list of causative verbs, but I think it would be sufficient to work with a dozen or less of the more common ones. If I weren’t able to teach this topic based on a textbook unit and the choice of presentation rested solely with me, it would seem logical to first present a good mix (4-6) of causative verbs in a cohesive context and encourage students to grasp the common semantic thread in all the examples. After this, I’d present groups of causative verbs based on the patterns they follow.

I’ll offer an activity or two for causative verbs in my next post.

Sources:

Biber, D.,  Conrad, S., and Leech, G. (2002). Longman student grammar of spoken and written English. Essex, England: Pearson Longman.

Biber, D.,  Johansson, S., Leech, G., Conrad, S. and Finnegan, E. (1999). Longman grammar of spoken and written English. Essex, England: Pearson Longman.

Fuchs, M. and Bonner, M. (2006). Focus on grammar 4: an integrated skills approach. White Plains, NY: Pearson Longman.
Explore posts in the same categories: Student Stumpers

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

12 Comments on “Student Stumper 24: Causative Verbs”

  1. sultan23c Says:

    I want to thank you for these fantastic lessons.You are the best teacher! God bless you. (SULTAN23C)EC member.


  2. [...] than a year ago, I was almost stumped by a question about causative verbs. In Student Stumper 24, I explored what causative verbs are and the patterns they follow. I also offered [...]


  3. What are cauasitve verbs? How are they formed, their perticular usage. and all key points about causative verbs.

  4. xuhaib Says:

    kindly post few example of get and make causative structure…


  5. […] and Quick discuss this pattern with perceptual verbs (as well as causative verbs) under the heading Direct object and bare infinitive clause (351).  When you say that you see […]

  6. randeep Says:

    Thank you teacher for providing the lessons, you are really the best.
    Could you please tell me what are semi-causative/first causative verbs? How can we use them effectively? While making typical causative sentences, which form is used as the base form of a verb i.e. Intransitive form or Semi-causative form? Can both of the forms be used while making a causative sentence i.e. Both Intransitive and semi-causative?
    ex:- 1. lie – intransitive, lay – semi-causative
    2. eat – intransitive, feed – semi-causative
    3. read/study – intransitive, teach – semi-causative
    Could you please provide the complete list of Semi-causative verbs along with their meanings?


    • Hello Randeep. You flatter me by attributing to me more knowledge than I have! :) Thank you for your belief in my knowledge, but on this particular topic, I may need to do more research. Previous research didn’t lead me to a list of so-called semi-causative verbs in English. Are you considering the use of ergative verbs with causative verbs? Both transitive and intransitive verbs are possible. It just depends on the situation. Here are two examples that come to mind:
      1. He let the door close. (“close” = intransitive)
      2. He made me eat it. (“eat” = transitive)

      • randeep Says:

        Hello Madam. Thank you for the reply. Ergative verb can be either transitive or intransitive. Could you provide the list of all ergative verbs? My previous question was something like this “can lay, teach and eat be used with have and get causative verbs?”. if yes, please give some examples along with their meanings. If teach and lay can be used in a causative sentence then when can learn and lie be used? How semi-causative verbs can be made? Can semi-causative/first causative be made by using causative verb/second causative? if yes, please provide the rule by which it can be used.


      • Hello. Have you searched through Google?
        Here are some links to check out.

        http://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/english-grammar/verbs/reflexive-and-ergative-verbs

        http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Category:English_ergative_verbs

        More examples:
        1. How do you get kids to eat vegetables?
        2. As a teacher trainer, I may have a trainee teach a lesson under my supervision.
        3. I got the dog to calm down and lay its head on my lap.

        Have a good day!

  7. randeep Says:

    Hello Madam. Thank you for the reply. Ergative verb can be either transitive or intransitive. Could you provide the list of all ergative verbs? My previous question was something like this “Can “lay”, “teach” and “eat” be used with “have” and “get” causative verbs?”. if yes, please give some examples along with their meanings. If “teach” and “lay” can be used in a causative sentence then when can “learn” and “lie” be used? How semi-causative verbs can be made? Can semi-causative/first causative be made by using causative verb/second causative? if yes, please provide the rule by which it can be used.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 719 other followers

%d bloggers like this: